index.md 11.8 KB
Newer Older
1
# **Cloud of Shame** LifeBuzz by LifeBuzz Media
2

3
![The Lifebuzz.com web site](/spotlight/lifebuzz.com/lifebuzz.jpg)
4

5
> You’ll never believe how many trackers this ONE web site has. – Ed.
6

7
8
## Is this the worst site on the web?

9
**LifeBuzz’s 172 trackers costs Americans over $4M a month in mobile data charges.**
10

11
The web is a sewer but some sites take things to altogether new and absurd levels. In our study of the top 5,000 web sites according to Alexa, LifeBuzz topped our list with 172 unique third-party trackers.
12

13
**Every time you load LifeBuzz, those 172 trackers waste 2.58MB of data[*](#after-better) and a little over 2 minutes of load time.[*](#after-better)** (Not coincidentally, those are also the amounts that Better saves you on every load.)
14

15
Those numbers alone are shocking, however, what’s really staggering is when you take into consideration that LifeBuzz gets over 250,000,000 page views a month[1](#references). This means that every month, **LifeBuzz wastes approximately 645 terabytes of our bandwidth and over 1,000 years of time just to load its trackers[8, 9](#references)**.
16

17
It gets worse: given the percentage of LifeBuzz’s traffic that’s from the US[5](#references) and the percentage of traffic in the US that’s from mobile phones[3](#references), we can calculate – conservatively – that **LifeBuzz wastes over 314 terabytes of mobile data in the US every month**[11](#references). Given that the average cost of 1GB of data in the US is $13.01[2](#references), **LifeBuzz costs Americans over $4,000,000 in mobile data charges alone every month[12](#references)**.
18

19
All that extra loading time also translates into wasted electricity. Again, to be as conservative as we can in our estimates, let’s assume that every one of LifeBuzz’s mobile users has the most energy efficient phone possible and gets close to 31 hours of web browsing on one fully-charged battery[6](#references). Even then, it would mean that **over 240,000 extra charges of mobile phones a month can be attributed to the energy wasted by the trackers on this one site**[10](#references). To further put this into perspective, the amount of energy wasted per month for all these additional charges is more than the amount of energy the average household in Brazil uses in a year[7, 13, & 14](#references).
20
21
22

Again, don’t forget that this is just one site – albeit, quite possibly, the worst site on the web.

23
**Consider now that the web today basically runs on behavioural advertising and tracking.** Think of the millions upon millions of sites that take part in this business model. Consider the mind-boggling amount of time, energy and resources wasted. To say nothing about the *qualitative impact* that this mass erosion of privacy has on our societies and on democracy.
24

25
So the next time you hear the behavioural advertising industry playing the victim and whining about how *their rights* are being trampled on by content blockers like Better, ask yourself who are the real victims here? The multi-billion-dollar monopolies carrying out mass surveillance on the world’s population for financial gain or the individuals who are trying to protect themselves from it?
26

27
**If you are a policymaker, here are the numbers you need – and the arguments you need – to do your job and to regulate this toxic industry.** You have no excuse not to. We cannot tie the future digital infrastructure of our lives to the toxic business model of tracking, analysing, and monetising people. [Ethical alternatives are possible](https://ind.ie/ethical-design) and it is up to you to support them while regulating the abuses of the current mainstream.
28

29
While LifeBuzz wins our first Cloud of Shame Award, we fear that it won’t be the last. If you know of any sites that are worthy of the honour, [please let us know](https://forum.ind.ie/c/better).
30
31
32

## Ethical design violations

33
34
(Learn more about [Ethical Design](https://ind.ie/ethical-design).)

35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
<!-- Automatic: the trackers list is generated and updated by Better Inspector. Please do not edit manually. -->
<!-- trackersList -->

  * Trackers
    * openx.net
    * googlesyndication.com
    * postrelease.com
    * ntv.io
    * nativeads.com
    * taboola.com
    * adblade.com
    * outbrain.com
    * ajax.googleapis.com
    * googleadservices.com
    * adnxs.com
    * google-analytics.com
    * scorecardresearch.com
    * fqtag.com
    * petametrics.com
    * facebook.net
    * doubleclick.net
    * facebook.com
    * googletagservices.com
    * quantserve.com
    * d31qbv1cthcecs.cloudfront.net
    * rlcdn.com
    * simpli.fi
    * crwdcntrl.net
    * google.com
    * d5nxst8fruw4z.cloudfront.net
    * amazonaws.com
    * google.se
    * exelator.com
68
    * a5224106a28855abbbb0825aa5e4cd9bd.profile.ams50.cloudfront.net
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
    * adkernel.com
    * atwola.com
    * reson8.com
    * gwallet.com
    * addthis.com
    * tubemogul.com
    * adx1.com
    * smartclip.net
    * cardlytics.com
    * tidaltv.com
    * rundsp.com
    * univide.com
    * tapad.com
    * connexity.net
    * mookie1.com
    * crispadvertising.com
    * krxd.net
    * w55c.net
    * wtp101.com
    * scanscout.com
    * bluekai.com
    * adap.tv
    * videohub.tv
    * serving-sys.com
    * btrll.com
    * adadvisor.net
    * yahoo.com
    * advertising.com
    * agkn.com
    * rubiconproject.com
    * eyeviewads.com
    * domdex.com
    * netmng.com
    * vindicosuite.com
    * sharethis.com
    * ml314.com
    * crisppremium.com
    * yume.com
    * criteo.com
    * mathtag.com
    * insightexpressai.com
    * prfct.co
    * undertone.com
    * bttrack.com
    * spongecell.com
    * rfihub.com
    * tribalfusion.com
    * dmtry.com
    * jumptap.com
    * adlucent.com
    * xg4ken.com
    * amgdgt.com
    * bing.com
    * flashtalking.com
    * bizographics.com
    * liverail.com
    * linkedin.com
    * lrcdn.net
    * hlserve.com
    * netseer.com
    * securedvisit.com
    * tekblue.net
    * optimahub.com
    * mxptint.net
    * pippio.com
    * skimresources.com
    * eyereturn.com
    * adgrx.com
    * choicestream.com
    * c1exchange.com
    * gumgum.com
    * revsci.net
    * spotxchange.com
    * wishabi.com
    * areyouahuman.com
    * atdmt.com
    * adbrn.com
    * weborama.fr
    * ketchuponnews.com
    * instinctiveads.com
    * dpclk.com
    * sundaysky.com
    * bidr.io
    * lijit.com
    * creditcards.com
    * bizrate.com
    * sonobi.com
    * ipowow.com
    * ib-ibi.com
    * clickagy.com
    * jivox.com
    * mdotm.com
    * 3lift.com
    * lifestreet.com
    * survata.com
    * conversionlogic.net
    * 33across.com
    * pubmatic.com
    * mediawallahscript.com
    * clrstm.com
    * thebrighttag.com
    * sitescout.com
    * jsrdn.com
    * company-target.com
    * ipredictive.com
    * pro-market.net
    * chango.com
    * crsspxl.com
    * owneriq.net
    * pricegrabber.com
    * swoop.com
    * mentad.com
    * sbal4kp.com
    * videoamp.com
    * bnmla.com
    * bdex.com
    * raasnet.com
    * ru4.com
    * adsrvr.org
    * turn.com
    * nexac.com
    * twitter.com
    * load.s3.amazonaws.com
    * casalemedia.com
    * collective-media.net
    * apxlv.com
    * cogocast.net
    * adsymptotic.com
    * zemanta.com
    * contextweb.com
    * afy11.net
    * uts-af.com
    * vmweb.net
    * opendsp.com
    * truoptik.com
    * visiblemeasures.com
    * eyeota.net
    * myvisualiq.net
    * ctnsnet.com
    * interstateanalytics.com
    * adform.net
    * appier.net
211
<!-- /trackersList -->
212
213
  * Clickbait
  * Web bug
Aral Balkan's avatar
Aral Balkan committed
214
215

<!--
216
217
218
219
220
  * Aggressive
  * Doorslam
  * Clickbait
  * Fingerprint
  * Web bug
Aral Balkan's avatar
Aral Balkan committed
221
-->
222
223
224
225

<!-- Automatic: the After Better section is generated and updated by Better Inspector. Please do not edit manually. -->
## After Better

Aral Balkan's avatar
Aral Balkan committed
226
227
228
  * Requests: <!-- requestsBefore -->708 requests<!-- /requestsBefore --> to <!-- requestsAfter -->42 requests<!-- /requestsAfter --> (<!-- requestsBlocked -->666 requests<!-- /requestsBlocked --> blocked, <!-- deltaRequests -->16.9× Safer<!-- /deltaRequests -->)
  * Weight: <!-- sizeBefore -->3.45 MB<!-- /sizeBefore --> to <!-- sizeAfter -->893.86 KB<!-- /sizeAfter --> (<!-- sizeSaved -->2.58 MB<!-- /sizeSaved --> saved, <!-- deltaSize -->4.0× Lighter<!-- /deltaSize -->)
  * Speed: <!-- timeBefore -->2.17 minutes<!-- /timeBefore --> to <!-- timeAfter -->8.27 seconds<!-- /timeAfter --> (<!-- timeSaved -->2.04 minutes<!-- /timeSaved --> saved, <!-- deltaTime -->15.8× Faster<!-- /deltaTime -->)
229

230
Statistics by [Better Inspector](https://source.ind.ie/better/inspector) based on [the page](https://archive.better.fyi/lifebuzz.com.har.gz) as on <!-- lastUpdate -->Sunday, April 24th 2016<!-- /lastUpdate -->
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246

<!-- Manual: Add block rules (site fixes, first-party blocking, etc.) for this site (if any), here.

## Block rules

### A block rule

Some explanation of the block rule.

```mson
- trigger:
  - url-filter: test.test
  - load-type: third-party
- action:
  - type: block
```
Aral Balkan's avatar
Aral Balkan committed
247
248
-->

249
250
251
252
253
254
255
## Notes

  * We could not find a privacy policy on LifeBuzz.com. (If there is one, it is not accessible from the main page or navigation.)
  * The owner, LifeBuzz Media, has a [privacy policy](http://www.lifebuzz.com/privacy/).
  * “We allow third party companies to serve ads and/or collect [data about you] when you visit our Web site. These companies may use [this data] (e.g. click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements” [Source](http://www.lifebuzz.com/privacy/)

## Screenshots
256

257
258
![LifeBuzz: Measured Results](/spotlight/lifebuzz.com/measured-results.jpg)

259
> LifeBuzz Media promises customers ‘measured results’ and a ‘highly engaged audience’. – Ed.
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268

![LifeBuzz: Most valuable audience](/spotlight/lifebuzz.com/most-valuable-audience.png)

> You’re very valuable to LifeBuzz. You’re the product they sell to their customers. – Ed.

![LifeBuzz: Most responsive traffic](/spotlight/lifebuzz.com/most-responsive-traffic.png)

> Is this what they mean by ‘responsive design?’ – Ed.

269
270
## References

271
  1. LifeBuzz.com gets “over 250,000,000 page views a month” [LifeBuzz](http://www.lifebuzzmedia.com)
272
273
  2. The average price of 1GB of mobile data in the US is $13.01 (2013) [Forbes](http://www.forbes.com/sites/tristanlouis/2013/09/22/the-real-price-of-wireless-data/#1fc4c421354e)
  3. 56% of traffic in the US is from mobile (2015) [SimilarWeb via MarketingLand](http://marketingland.com/mobile-top-sites-165725)
274
275
276
277
  4. 82% of LifeBuzz’s traffic is from mobile [LifeBuzz](http://www.lifebuzzmedia.com)
  5. 87% of LifeBuzz’s traffic is from the US [LifeBuzz](http://www.lifebuzzmedia.com)
  6. The Gionee Marathon M5 is the most energy efficient phone in the [GSM Arena Battery Test](http://www.gsmarena.com/battery-test.php3). It gets 30:51 hours of web browsing on a single charge (= 1,851 minutes)
  7.[G]iving a full charge to an iPhone 6 uses about 10.5 watt-hours of electricity.” [Opower](https://blog.opower.com/2014/09/iphone-6-charging-47-cents/)
278
279
  8. 250,000,000 page-views/month (see 1) × 2.58 MB wasted (see [above](#after-better))= 645,000 GB wasted/month
  9. 250,000,000 page-views/month (see 1) × 2.17 minutes wasted (see [above](#after-better)) = 542,500,000 minutes wasted/month = 1,031.45 years
280
  10. 542,500,000 minutes wasted/month (see 9) × 0.82 (see 4) ÷ 1,851 minutes (see 6) = 240,329.55159 extra mobile phone battery charges/month
281
  11. 645,000 GB wasted/month (see 8) × 0.87 (see 5) * 0.56 (see 3) = 314,244 GB of US mobile data wasted/month
282
  12. 314,244 GB of US mobile data wasted/month (see 11) × $13.01 (see 2) = $4,088,314.44 wasted in data costs/month
283
284
  13. 240,329.55159 extra mobile phone battery charges/month (see 10) × 10.5 watt-hours (see 7) = 2,523,460.2917 watt-hours of energy wasted = 2,523.4602917 Kw/h
  14. Household electricity consumption (kWh/year) – Brazil: 1,834, Russia: 2,419, Italy: 2,777. [World Energy Council](http://shrinkthatfootprint.com/average-household-electricity-consumption)
285

286
287
288